+25 Best Eyeliner Pencils in 2021 (Top-rated Reviews)


Sharing is caring!

Pencil or pen eyeliners are an essential part of everyday makeup.

Everyone likes elegant eyes, so do you. You can have elegant eyes by using the best eyeliner pencils  as simple as that

The +25 best eyeliner pencils you should consider to get any look you want whether that is for an evening party or day time look. If you check women’s bags you will definitely find one and this is so natural.

There are eyeliners that you can only apply to lash lines but now there are many eyeliners in the market that you can apply to lash as well as waterline too. Many products also come with a vegan tag. 

But seriously I feel using a pencil or pen eyeliner is way better than struggling with the liquid eyeliner. If you are a beginner then you must start with the pencil or pen eyeliners.

Stay beautiful at all times with the best eyeliner pencils or pens for any type of occasion.

+25 Best Eyeliner Pencils (top-rated Reviews)

+25 Best Eyeliner Pencils (Top-rated Reviews)

source: Befunky 

1. Best Eyeliner Pencil: M.A.C Technakohl Liner - Graphblack

M.A.C Technakohl Liner
M.A.C Technakohl Liner - Graphblack

M.A.C Technakohl Graph black Pencil style Liner

The formula of this product is creamy with intense and rich colour. It blends smoothly when you are applying the product. Versatile eyeliners that have drying time so quick and also smudge-free. You can use this eyeliner on the top and lower lash of the eyes. 

For getting the different look you have to use it proper manner like when you required precision line eyeliner in a 90-degree angle and for thicker application apply in a flat line. Draw in the desired shape along with the lash line as required upper or lower.


What people are saying..

Of all the pencil eye liners on the market, this one is by far my favorite! It is dark, I do not have to sharpen it, and it stays on relatively well. Its not waterproof or 24 hr but that is fine with me.

2. Best Eyeliner Pencil: M.A.C Dual Dare All - Day Waterproof Liner

Waterproof Eyeliner
Day Waterproof Liner

M.A.C Dual Dare All-Day Waterproof Liner

This is an artist’s tool for double effect and to give enhanced self- expressions. Two-in-one waterproof and matte black linear which has multiple ways to work. 

One end gives cleaned and precise wings line how you want and another site is kajal pencil for the bendable smoked out smudges. Liner site of liner you can apply on lash line but kajal site you can apply for both lash line and water lines.


What people are saying..

It stays for quite a long time it's intense and hold, Smudge proof gives a wonderful look eye look fully recommend it to everyone..

Bobbi Brown Ink Liner
Blackest Black Liner

Bobbi Brown Ink Liner, Blackest Black

This is a pen-style liner that gives intense black colour after application. This eyeliner doesn’t fade, flake or smudge. It is a flexible tip application which delivers carbon pigments with extreme precision and colour intensity is a rich black

It glides evenly and smoothly during application. This is the perfect eyeliner for every occasion.

You can try it out with different shapes on your eyes. It has a stunning impact to shape the eyes.


What people are saying..

This is a more expensive liner, but it lasts forever. I would have made three trips to the drug store by now to buy the cheap stuff.

MyGlamm Kajal Eyeliner

Kajal Eyeliner - Jet Black

MyGlamm Jet Set Eyes Kajal Eyeliner, Jet Black

This comes in three different shades. Noir is the black colour and the other two shades are Bleu (i.e blue) and Brun (i.e brown). It is also PETA Approved cruelty-free and vegan

MyGlamm’s Jet Set Eyes kohl is a rich pigmented and pencil glides on smoothly and delivers intense colour and curves. It is a twisted pencil design for precise, easy-glide applications whenever you are applying.

It’s waterproof, smudge and transfer-resistant, enriched with natural antioxidants.


What people are saying..

This Kajal gives instant black shad and this is good for daily wear.

Its stay is also very good it stays for 6 to 7 hours on your eyes my eyes look beautiful after applying this Kajal good product to buy

Pencil Eyeliner Midnight Moon + Silver Rush

Kajal Eyeliner - Jet Black

MyGlamm Jet Set Eyes Kajal Eyeliner, Jet Black

Every eyeliner pencil comes with a twist of two different colours with classic black shade on one side and a dazzling jewel-toned colour on the other. 

It glides smoothly during application and gives a rich colour and can be blended to give a dramatic effect. You can wear these shades individually or you can mix these and make some different shades. 

You can create different looks in single strokes. It contains mineral-based powder, such as zeolite, to support blendability to create smoky eyes. Jewel-toned shades contain hyper-emollient ester for a shiny glam finish.


Gel Crayon Eyeliner
L'Oreal Paris Infallible Gel Crayon Eye Liner

L’Oreal Paris Infallible Gel Crayon Eye Liner, 101 Back to Black

L’Oreal Paris Infallible Gel Crayon Eyeliner comes in 11 different shades, now you can give intense colour and volume to your eyes with these super amazing shades. 

It is one of the best gel crayon eyeliner which has a heavy pigment load that can stay up to 24 hours, with a smooth glide of gel crayon in pencil form. Get an ultra-bold and long-lasting colour to eyes with 11 different shades.


What people are saying..

I am a fan of its smoothness and smudge-proof formulation.. but it doesn't come with a sharpener...

Maybelline best Eyeliner Pencil

Maybelline Crayon Eyeliner - Black

Maybelline New York Line Tattoo Crayon Eyelner, Black

This is the 1st tattoo-like liner in a crayon pencil applicator which gives you up to 36 hours of wear time. It gives intense colour after application, in one stroke with the pencil you can change the overall appearance of your eyes. 

This product lasts over a long day. It is a creamy formula that glides very smoothly. It is waterproof, smudge-proof, and sweatproof.


What people are saying..

Easier to apply on your hand then on eyelid as it’s not smooth application gel-type liner .. so one has to pull the eyelid and apply with little pressure which is not really recommended..

however it stays really long and mess free smudge free as advertised.. average product..delivery takes long time

Colorbar All - Rounder Pencil

Rounder Pencil

Colorbar All-Rounder Pencil-Blingy Bronze, Brown

This product is formulated in Germany, this is three in one product you can use this as a kajal, eyeliner as well as lip liner too. 

It gives intense long-lasting retention which lasts up to 16 hours. It is a big pigment formula for Kajal and eyeliner. In just one stroke you can get vibrant looks.


What people are saying..

Love the product..

Cosmetics Roller Liner
Brown Eyeliner Pencil

Benefit Cosmetics Roller Liner Brown Eyeliner Pencil

This product comes in two different shades i.e black and brown. Roller liner which gives natural-looking fine. It glides very smoothly and gives fine lines and different strokes as you want. Matte eyeliner which has felt tip for sharp lines and super smooth application. 

It dries very quickly and long-wearing lasts over 24 hours. It doesn’t fade and smudge. You can use this anytime whether going out in the day or for a party at night. 

You can get perfect wings from the outer corner to your eyes and bring it towards the inner corner, connect the lines and get a perfect look!!!


Overstay Waterproof Eyeliner
Quick Drying & Waterproof

SUGAR Cosmetics Arrested For Overstay Waterproof Eyeliner – 01 I’ll Be Black (Black) | Quick Drying & Waterproof

The Sugar Arrested For Overstay Waterproof Eyeliner pen glides on smoothly and stays for a long time. 

Precision tip for complete control over your eyes, the eyeliner can draw the lines how you want, you can also build a more dramatic look. The pigment is blacker and won’t fade or melt. This formula is 100% waterproof.


What people are saying..

Very easy to apply and stays for a really long time. I once slept off forgetting to take my makeup off and woke up with the eyeliner intact.

But if not used regularly, it will dry out and is unusable.

NYX Professional Makeup Ink Liner

Ink Eye Liner

Nyx Professional Makeup Epic Ink Eye Liner, Black

You get smooth strokes and shapes with  NYX Professional’s limited-edition Love Lust Disco Epic Ink Liner. It gives a satiny smooth finish and also glides very smoothly. 

You can create thin or thick looks depending on your mood with precision. Also, you can make perfect wings with a single stroke.

This felt tip eyeliner is loaded with intense black pigments for a one-stroke colour pay off.


What people are saying..

I just loved it also got a free gift from seller nyx round lipstic chaos nice shade thanks amazon and to the seller. eyeliner is simple cool now i can daily wing my eyes

Easy Liquid Eyelining Pen
Clinique Pretty Easy Liquid Eyelining Pen

Clinique Pretty Easy Liquid Eyelining Pen | Precision Brush with 24-Hour Smudge and Budge-Resistant Wear | Black 

Clinique’s pen creates a clean line in one steady sweep. You can draw thick and thick lines as you want with the precision brush. 

It is a long-lasting formula with smudge-proof and budge resistant. Long-wearing up to 24 hours. The product that actively improves your skin without irritation.


What people are saying..

I cannot live without this. I have tried around 30 black eyeliner pens and none eve come close to this. So pigmented and so precise 🙂

M.A.C Brushstroke Liner - Brushblack

M.A.C Brushstroke Liner

M.A.C Brushstroke Liner Brushblack

Brushstroke Liner has a precision brush tip that makes liquid lining sharp, fast, and easy. This pen eyeliner creates thin as well as thick curves easily

You may also draw the finest lines with this. The product is smudge-proof, budge resistant with intense colour in black or brown that wears strong all day long, yet removes easily.


What people are saying..

My absolute favorite eyeliner. I've tried hundreds of liquid liners and this one kicks but. It lasts long and makes application easy. The first time you apply it, it seems this and not solid but the brush just needs to dampen up.

Lakme Absolute Silk Eyeliner

Lakme Silk Eyeliner

Lakme Absolute Forever Silk Eyeliner, Blue Cosmos

This product contains vitamin E that gives moisturizes along with soft, creamy texture. You can create metallic hues for eyes in a single application of this product. 

It can stay for about 8 hours, waterproof, and smudge-free. It comes in vibrant shades.


What people are saying..

Well.. I don't like flashy colours.. this colour is a nice blue on the darker side.. u can wear it daily and it goes wid most outfits.. the eyeliner is smooth. . And the pencil is non retractable. . Meaning it can only b rotated upwards and not downward..

Ultime Pro Ink Eyeliner

Lakme Silk Eyeliner

Faces Canada Ultime Pro A Matte Made in Heaven Ink liner 1.2 ml (Black)

This product is made in Germany and you can get bold and jet back eyes with this Face Canada Ultime Pro A Matte Made In Heaven Ink Eyeliner. It gives a super matte finish. You can also create fine lines, wings with precision.

This is highly pigmented eyeliner in pen format which gives quick-drying property and matte finish within the seconds.


What people are saying..

I just loved it. After buying 5 eyelines of different brand i tried this with doubt.but it has ol that i required.pointed tip,darker,smudge proof,easily removable,nd matte look......

Maybelline Hyper Sharp Liner

Maybelline Sharp Liner

Maybelline New York Alice + Olivia Limited Edition Hyper Sharp Liner, 0.5g

Coloressence Best EyeLiner Pencil

Eye Liner Pencil

Eye Liner Pencil – Peacock Blue

One Stroke Waterproof Eyeliner
One Stroke Eyeliner Kajal

Miss Claire One Stroke Eyeliner Kajal 1.2gm

Black - L'Oreal Paris Flash Cat Eye Eyeliner
Flash Cat Eyeliner by SuperLiner

L’Oreal Paris Flash Cat Eye Eyeliner, Black, 0.6 ml

Ultime Pro Eyestyle Liner
Faces Canada Eyetyle Liner Black

Faces Canada Ultime Pro Eyetyle Liner Black 1 ml (Black)

Lakme Eyeconic Liner Pen
Lakme Liner Pen Fine Tip - Deep Black

Lakme Eyeconic Fine Tip Liner Pen, Black, 1ml

Maybelline Gel EyeLiner - Black
Maybelline Gigi Hadid Gel EyeLiner

Black, 0.037 Ounce: Maybelline New York Gigi Hadid Gel Eyeliner, Black

Lakme Liner Pen Block Tip - Deep Black
Lakme Eyeconic Liner Pen Block Tip

Lakmé Eyeconic Block Tip Liner Pen, Black

Faces Canada Ultime Pro Ink Eyeliner
Faces Canada Ink Eyeliner

Faces Canada Ultime Pro A Matte Made in Heaven Ink liner

Blue Heaven Soft Kajal Eye Liner
Soft Kajal Eye Liner

Blue Heaven Soft Kajal Eyeliner, Blue


Actually this totally depends upon what features you are looking for in the pencil eyeliner I suggest this product M.A.C Dual Dare All-Day Waterproof Liner because it is two-in-one waterproof, matte, intense black cloud and stays for a longer time.

Both the product formats deliver their own benefits but if you are a beginner then go for pencil eyeliners.

Kajal Eyeliner works two ways and acts as a kajal as well as an eyeliner, which is safe to use on the waterline. These are mostly rich pigmented pencils glides on smoothly and delivering intense definition.

Yes, you can use kajal eyeliners on lash as well as waterline also. Sometimes these products can be used as an eyeshadow base and for creating a smokey eye look.

You should apply eyeliner to the lash line of upper eyelids. Try out these above best pencil or pen eyeliners.

Sharing is caring!

Leave a Comment